types.ml

open Recursive
open Printf
open Ident

(* IDEAS for optimizations:

  * optimize lines of dnf for products and record;
    instead of
      (t1,s1) & ... & (tn,sn) \ ....
    use:
      (t1 & ... & tn, s1 & ... & sn) \ ....

    ---> more compact representation, more sharing, ...
 
  * re-consider using BDD-like representation instead of dnf
*)


let map_sort f l =
  SortedList.from_list (List.map f l)

module HashedString = 
struct 
  type t = string 
  let hash = Hashtbl.hash
  let equal = (=)
end


type const = 
  | Integer of Intervals.v
  | Atom of Atoms.v
  | Char of Chars.v

type pair_kind = [ `Normal | `XML ]

type 'a node0 = { id : int; mutable descr : 'a }

module NodePair = struct
  type 'a t = 'a node0 * 'a node0
  let compare (x1,y1) (x2,y2) =
    if x1.id < x2.id then -1
    else if x1.id > x2.id then 1
    else y1.id - y2.id
  let equal (x1,y1) (x2,y2) = (x1==x2) && (y1==y2)
  let hash (x,y) = x.id + 17 * y.id
end 

module RecArg = struct
  type 'a t = bool * 'a node0 label_map
  
  let rec compare_rec r1 r2 =
    if r1 == r2 then 0
    else match (r1,r2) with
      | (l1,x1)::r1,(l2,x2)::r2 ->
	  if ((l1:int) < l2) then -1 
	  else if (l1 > l2) then 1 
	  else if x1.id < x2.id then -1
	  else if x1.id > x2.id then 1
	  else compare_rec r1 r2
      | ([],_) -> -1
      | _ -> 1

  let compare (o1,r1) (o2,r2) =
    if o1 && not o2 then -1 
    else if o2 && not o1 then 1
    else compare_rec (LabelMap.get r1) (LabelMap.get r2)

  let rec equal_rec r1 r2 =
    (r1 == r2) ||
    match (r1,r2) with
      | (l1,x1)::r1,(l2,x2)::r2 ->
	  (x1.id == x2.id) && (l1 == l2) && (equal_rec r1 r2)
      | _ -> false

  let equal (o1,r1) (o2,r2) =
    (o1 == o2) && (equal_rec (LabelMap.get r1) (LabelMap.get r2))

  let rec hash_rec accu = function
    | (l,x)::rem -> hash_rec (257 * accu + 17 * l + x.id) rem
    | [] -> accu + 5
      
  let hash (o,r) = hash_rec (if o then 2 else 1) (LabelMap.get r)
end

module BoolPair = Boolean.Make(NodePair)
module BoolRec = Boolean.Make(RecArg)

type descr = {
  atoms : Atoms.t;
  ints  : Intervals.t;
  chars : Chars.t;
  times : descr BoolPair.t;
  xml   : descr BoolPair.t;
  arrow : descr BoolPair.t;
  record: descr BoolRec.t;
  absent: bool
} and node = descr node0

	       
let empty = { 
  times = BoolPair.empty; 
  xml   = BoolPair.empty; 
  arrow = BoolPair.empty; 
  record= BoolRec.empty;
  ints  = Intervals.empty;
  atoms = Atoms.empty;
  chars = Chars.empty;
  absent= false;
}
	      
let any =  {
  times = BoolPair.full; 
  xml   = BoolPair.full; 
  arrow = BoolPair.full; 
  record= BoolRec.full; 
  ints  = Intervals.any;
  atoms = Atoms.any;
  chars = Chars.any;
  absent= false;
}
	     
	     
let interval i = { empty with ints = i }
let times x y = { empty with times = BoolPair.atom (x,y) }
let xml x y = { empty with xml = BoolPair.atom (x,y) }
let arrow x y = { empty with arrow = BoolPair.atom (x,y) }
let record label t = 
  { empty with record = BoolRec.atom (true,LabelMap.singleton label t) }
let record' (x : bool * node Ident.label_map) =
  { empty with record = BoolRec.atom x }
let atom a = { empty with atoms = a }
let char c = { empty with chars = c }
let constant = function
  | Integer i -> interval (Intervals.atom i)
  | Atom a -> atom (Atoms.atom a)
  | Char c -> char (Chars.atom c)
      
let cup x y = 
  if x == y then x else {
    times = BoolPair.cup x.times y.times;
    xml   = BoolPair.cup x.xml y.xml;
    arrow = BoolPair.cup x.arrow y.arrow;
    record= BoolRec.cup x.record y.record;
    ints  = Intervals.cup x.ints  y.ints;
    atoms = Atoms.cup x.atoms y.atoms;
    chars = Chars.cup x.chars y.chars;
    absent= x.absent || y.absent;
  }
    
let cap x y = 
  if x == y then x else {
    times = BoolPair.cap x.times y.times;
    xml   = BoolPair.cap x.xml y.xml;
    record= BoolRec.cap x.record y.record;
    arrow = BoolPair.cap x.arrow y.arrow;
    ints  = Intervals.cap x.ints  y.ints;
    atoms = Atoms.cap x.atoms y.atoms;
    chars = Chars.cap x.chars y.chars;
    absent= x.absent && y.absent;
  }
    
let diff x y = 
  if x == y then empty else {
    times = BoolPair.diff x.times y.times;
    xml   = BoolPair.diff x.xml y.xml;
    arrow = BoolPair.diff x.arrow y.arrow;
    record= BoolRec.diff x.record y.record;
    ints  = Intervals.diff x.ints  y.ints;
    atoms = Atoms.diff x.atoms y.atoms;
    chars = Chars.diff x.chars y.chars;
    absent= x.absent && not y.absent;
  }
    

let rec compare_rec r1 r2 =
  if r1 == r2 then 0
  else match (r1,r2) with
    | (l1,x1)::r1,(l2,x2)::r2 ->
	if ((l1:int) < l2) then -1 
	else if (l1 > l2) then 1 
	else if x1.id < x2.id then -1
	else if x1.id > x2.id then 1
	else compare_rec r1 r2
    | ([],_) -> -1
    | _ -> 1

let rec compare_rec_list l1 l2  =
  if l1 == l2 then 0 
  else match (l1,l2) with
    | (o1,r1)::l1, (o2,r2)::l2 ->
	if o2 && not o1 then -1
	else if o1 && not o2 then 1
	else let c = compare_rec r1 r2 in if c <> 0 then c 
	else compare_rec_list l1 l2
    | ([],_) -> -1
    | _ -> 1

let rec compare_rec_bool l1 l2  =
  if l1 == l2 then 0 
  else match (l1,l2) with
    | (p1,n1)::l1, (p2,n2)::l2 ->
	let c = compare_rec_list p1 p2 in if c <> 0 then c 
	else let c = compare_rec_list n1 n2 in if c <> 0 then c 
	else compare_rec_bool l1 l2
    | ([],_) -> -1
    | _ -> 1

let rec compare_times_list l1 l2  =
  if l1 == l2 then 0 
  else match (l1,l2) with
    | (x1,y1)::l1, (x2,y2)::l2 ->
	if (x1.id < x2.id) then -1
	else if (x1.id > x2.id) then 1 
	else if (y1.id < y2.id) then -1
	else if (y1.id > y2.id) then 1 
	else compare_times_list l1 l2
    | ([],_) -> -1
    | _ -> 1

let rec compare_times_bool l1 l2  =
  if l1 == l2 then 0 
  else match (l1,l2) with
    | (p1,n1)::l1, (p2,n2)::l2 ->
	let c = compare_times_list p1 p2 in if c <> 0 then c 
	else let c = compare_times_list n1 n2 in if c <> 0 then c 
	else compare_times_bool l1 l2
    | ([],_) -> -1
    | _ -> 1
	     
let rec equal_rec r1 r2 =
  (r1 == r2) ||
  match (r1,r2) with
    | (l1,x1)::r1,(l2,x2)::r2 ->
	(x1.id = x2.id) && (l1 == l2) && (equal_rec r1 r2)
    | _ -> false
	
let rec equal_rec_list l1 l2  =
  (l1 == l2) ||
  match (l1,l2) with
    | (o1,r1)::l1, (o2,r2)::l2 ->
	(o1 == o2) &&
	(equal_rec r1 r2) && (equal_rec_list l1 l2)
    | _ -> false
	
let rec equal_rec_bool l1 l2 =
  (l1 == l2) ||
  match (l1,l2) with
    | (p1,n1)::l1, (p2,n2)::l2 -> 
	(equal_rec_list p1 p2) &&
	(equal_rec_list n1 n2) &&
        (equal_rec_bool l1 l2)
    | _ -> false
	
let rec equal_times_list l1 l2  =
  (l1 == l2) ||
  match (l1,l2) with
    | (x1,y1)::l1, (x2,y2)::l2 -> 
	(x1.id = x2.id) &&
	(y1.id = y2.id) &&
	(equal_times_list l1 l2)
    | _ -> false
	
let rec equal_times_bool l1 l2 =
  (l1 == l2) ||
  match (l1,l2) with
    | (p1,n1)::l1, (p2,n2)::l2 -> 
	(equal_times_list p1 p2) &&
	(equal_times_list n1 n2) &&
        (equal_times_bool l1 l2)
    | _ -> false
	
let equal_descr a b =
  (Atoms.equal a.atoms b.atoms) &&
  (Chars.equal a.chars b.chars) &&
  (Intervals.equal a.ints  b.ints) &&
  (BoolPair.equal a.times b.times) &&
  (BoolPair.equal a.xml b.xml) &&
  (BoolPair.equal a.arrow b.arrow) &&
  (BoolRec.equal a.record b.record) &&
  (a.absent == b.absent)

let compare_descr a b =
  if a == b then 0 
  else let c = Atoms.compare a.atoms b.atoms in if c <> 0 then c
  else let c = compare a.chars b.chars in if c <> 0 then c
  else let c = compare a.ints b.ints in if c <> 0 then c
  else let c = BoolPair.compare a.times b.times in if c <> 0 then c
  else let c = BoolPair.compare a.xml b.xml in if c <> 0 then c
  else let c = BoolPair.compare a.arrow b.arrow in if c <> 0 then c
  else let c = BoolRec.compare a.record b.record in if c <> 0 then c
  else if a.absent && not b.absent then -1
  else if b.absent && not a.absent then 1
  else 0

(*
let compare_descr a b =
  let c = compare_descr a b in
  assert (c = compare a b);
  c
*)


let rec hash_times_list accu = function
  | (x,y)::l ->
      hash_times_list (accu * 257 + x.id * 17 + y.id) l
  | [] -> accu + 17
      
let rec hash_times_bool accu = function
  | (p,n)::l -> 
      hash_times_bool (hash_times_list (hash_times_list accu p) n) l
  | [] -> accu + 3
      
let rec hash_rec accu = function
  | (l,x)::rem ->
      hash_rec (257 * accu + 17 * (LabelPool.hash l) + x.id) rem
  | [] -> accu + 5
      
let rec hash_rec_list accu = function
  | (o,r)::l ->
      hash_rec_list (hash_rec (if o then accu*3 else accu) r) l
  | [] -> accu + 17
      
let rec hash_rec_bool accu = function
  | (p,n)::l -> 
      hash_rec_bool (hash_rec_list (hash_rec_list accu p) n) l
  | [] -> accu + 3
      
      
let hash_descr a =
  let accu = Chars.hash 1 a.chars in
  let accu = Intervals.hash accu a.ints in
  let accu = Atoms.hash accu a.atoms in
  let accu = 17 * accu + BoolPair.hash a.times in
  let accu = 17 * accu + BoolPair.hash a.xml in
  let accu = 17 * accu + BoolPair.hash a.arrow in
  let accu = 17 * accu + BoolRec.hash a.record in
  let accu = if a.absent then accu+5 else accu in
  accu


module DescrHash = 
  Hashtbl.Make(
    struct 
      type t = descr
      let hash = hash_descr
      let equal = equal_descr
    end
  )

let hash_cons = DescrHash.create 17000

let count = ref 0
let make () = incr count; { id = !count; descr = empty }
let define n d = 
(*  DescrHash.add hash_cons d n; *)
  n.descr <- d
let cons d = 
  (* try DescrHash.find hash_cons d with Not_found ->
  incr count; let n = { id = !count; descr = d } in
  DescrHash.add hash_cons d n; n *)
  incr count; { id = !count; descr = d }
let descr n = n.descr
let internalize n = n
let id n = n.id




let print_descr = ref (fun _ _  -> assert false)

let neg x = diff any x

let any_node = cons any

module LabelS = Set.Make(LabelPool)

let get_record r =
  let labs accu (_,r) = 
    List.fold_left 
      (fun accu (l,_) -> LabelS.add l accu) accu (LabelMap.get r) in
  let extend descrs labs (o,r) =
    let rec aux i labs r =
      match labs with
	| [] -> ()
	| l1::labs ->
	    match r with
	      | (l2,x)::r when l1 == l2 -> 
		  descrs.(i) <- cap descrs.(i) (descr x);
		  aux (i+1) labs r
	      | r ->
		  if not o then descrs.(i) <- 
		    cap descrs.(i) { empty with absent = true };
		  aux (i+1) labs r
    in
    aux 0 labs (LabelMap.get r);
    o
  in
  let line (p,n) =
    let labels = 
      List.fold_left labs (List.fold_left labs LabelS.empty p) n in
    let labels = LabelS.elements labels in
    let nlab = List.length labels in
    let mk () = Array.create nlab { any with absent = true } in

    let pos = mk () in
    let opos = List.fold_left 
		 (fun accu x -> 
		    (extend pos labels x) && accu)
		 true p in
    let p = (opos, pos) in

    let n = List.map (fun x ->
			let neg = mk () in
			let o = extend neg labels x in
			(o,neg)
		     ) n in
    (labels,p,n)
  in
  List.map line (BoolRec.get r)
   

module DescrMap = Map.Make(struct type t = descr let compare = compare end)

let check d =
  BoolPair.check d.times;
  BoolPair.check d.xml;
  BoolPair.check d.arrow;
  BoolRec.check d.record;
  ()



(* Subtyping algorithm *)

let diff_t d t = diff d (descr t)
let cap_t d t = cap d (descr t)
let cup_t d t = cup d (descr t)
let cap_product l =
  List.fold_left 
    (fun (d1,d2) (t1,t2) -> (cap_t d1 t1, cap_t d2 t2))
    (any,any)
    l
let cup_product l =
  List.fold_left 
    (fun (d1,d2) (t1,t2) -> (cup_t d1 t1, cup_t d2 t2))
    (empty,empty)
    l

let rec exists max f =
  (max > 0) && (f (max - 1) || exists (max - 1) f)

let trivially_empty d = equal_descr d empty

exception NotEmpty

type slot = { mutable status : status; 
	       mutable notify : notify;
	       mutable active : bool }
and status = Empty | NEmpty | Maybe
and notify = Nothing | Do of slot * (slot -> unit) * notify

let memo = DescrHash.create 33000

let marks = ref [] 
let slot_empty = { status = Empty; active = false; notify = Nothing }
let slot_not_empty = { status = NEmpty; active = false; notify = Nothing }

let rec notify = function
  | Nothing -> ()
  | Do (n,f,rem) -> 
      if n.status = Maybe then (try f n with NotEmpty -> ());
      notify rem

let rec iter_s s f = function
  | [] -> ()
  | arg::rem -> f arg s; iter_s s f rem


let set s =
  s.status <- NEmpty;
  notify s.notify;
  s.notify <- Nothing; 
  raise NotEmpty

let rec big_conj f l n =
  match l with
    | [] -> set n
    | [arg] -> f arg n
    | arg::rem ->
	let s = { status = Maybe; active = false; notify = Do (n,(big_conj f rem), Nothing) } in
	try 
	  f arg s;
	  if s.active then n.active <- true
	with NotEmpty -> if n.status = NEmpty then raise NotEmpty

let rec guard a f n =
  match slot a with
    | { status = Empty } -> ()
    | { status = Maybe } as s -> n.active <- true; s.notify <- Do (n,f,s.notify)
    | { status = NEmpty } -> f n

and slot d =
  if not ((Intervals.is_empty d.ints) && 
	  (Atoms.is_empty d.atoms) &&
	  (Chars.is_empty d.chars) &&
	  (not d.absent)) then slot_not_empty 
  else try DescrHash.find memo d
  with Not_found ->
(*    Format.fprintf Format.std_formatter "Empty:%a@\n" !print_descr d; *)
    let s = { status = Maybe; active = false; notify = Nothing } in
    DescrHash.add memo d s;
    (try
       iter_s s check_times (BoolPair.get d.times);
       iter_s s check_times (BoolPair.get d.xml);
       iter_s s check_arrow (BoolPair.get d.arrow);
       iter_s s check_record (get_record d.record);
       if s.active then marks := s :: !marks else s.status <- Empty;
     with
	 NotEmpty -> ());
    s

and check_times (left,right) s =
(*  Printf.eprintf "[%i]" (List.length right);
  flush stderr;  *)
  let rec aux accu1 accu2 right s = match right with
    | (t1,t2)::right ->
	if trivially_empty (cap_t accu1 t1) || 
	   trivially_empty (cap_t accu2 t2) then (
	     aux accu1 accu2 right s )
	else (
          let accu1' = diff_t accu1 t1 in guard accu1' (aux accu1' accu2 right) s;
          let accu2' = diff_t accu2 t2 in guard accu2' (aux accu1 accu2' right) s 
	)
    | [] -> set s
  in
(*
  if List.length right > 6 then (
    Printf.eprintf "HEURISTIC\n"; flush stderr;
    let (n1,n2) = cup_product right in
    let n1 = diff accu1 n1 and n2 = diff accu2 n2 in
    guard n1 set s;
    guard n2 set s;
    Printf.eprintf "HEURISTIC failed\n"; flush stderr;
  ); *)
  let (accu1,accu2) = cap_product left in
  guard accu1 (guard accu2 (aux accu1 accu2 right)) s

and check_arrow (left,right) s =
  let single_right (s1,s2) s =
    let rec aux accu1 accu2 left s = match left with
      | (t1,t2)::left ->
          let accu1' = diff_t accu1 t1 in guard accu1' (aux accu1' accu2 left) s;
          let accu2' = cap_t  accu2 t2 in guard accu2' (aux accu1 accu2' left) s
      | [] -> set s
    in
    let accu1 = descr s1 in
    guard accu1 (aux accu1 (neg (descr s2)) left) s
  in
  big_conj single_right right s

and check_record (labels,(oleft,left),rights) s =
  let rec aux rights s = match rights with
    | [] -> set s
    | (oright,right)::rights ->
	let next =
	  (oleft && (not oright)) || (* ggg... why ???  check this line *)
	  exists (Array.length left)
	    (fun i ->
	       trivially_empty (cap left.(i) right.(i)))
	in
	if next then aux rights s
	else
	  for i = 0 to Array.length left - 1 do
	    let back = left.(i) in
	    let di = diff back right.(i) in
	    guard di (fun s ->
			left.(i) <- diff back right.(i);
			aux rights s;
			left.(i) <- back;
		     ) s
	  done
  in
  let rec start i s =
    if (i < 0) then aux rights s
    else
      guard left.(i) (start (i - 1)) s
  in
  start (Array.length left - 1) s


let is_empty d =
(*  Printf.eprintf "is_empty: start\n"; flush stderr; *)
  let s = slot d in
  List.iter 
    (fun s' -> if s'.status = Maybe then s'.status <- Empty; s'.notify <- Nothing) 
    !marks;
  marks := [];
(*  Printf.eprintf "is_empty: done\n"; flush stderr; *)
  s.status = Empty
  

module Assumptions = Set.Make(struct type t = descr let compare = compare_descr end)
let memo = ref Assumptions.empty
let cache_false = DescrHash.create 33000

let rec empty_rec d =
  if not (Intervals.is_empty d.ints) then false
  else if not (Atoms.is_empty d.atoms) then false
  else if not (Chars.is_empty d.chars) then false
  else if d.absent then false
  else if DescrHash.mem cache_false d then false 
  else if Assumptions.mem d !memo then true
  else (
    let backup = !memo in
    memo := Assumptions.add d backup;
    if 
      (empty_rec_times (BoolPair.get d.times)) &&
      (empty_rec_times (BoolPair.get d.xml)) &&
      (empty_rec_arrow (BoolPair.get d.arrow)) &&
      (empty_rec_record d.record) 
    then true
    else (
      memo := backup;
      DescrHash.add cache_false d ();
      false
    )
  )

and empty_rec_times c =
  List.for_all empty_rec_times_aux c

and empty_rec_times_aux (left,right) =
  let rec aux accu1 accu2 = function
    | (t1,t2)::right ->
	if trivially_empty (cap_t accu1 t1) || 
	   trivially_empty (cap_t accu2 t2) then
	  aux accu1 accu2 right
	else
          let accu1' = diff_t accu1 t1 in
          if not (empty_rec accu1') then aux accu1' accu2 right;
          let accu2' = diff_t accu2 t2 in
	  if not (empty_rec accu2') then aux accu1 accu2' right
    | [] -> raise NotEmpty
  in
  let (accu1,accu2) = cap_product left in
  (empty_rec accu1) || (empty_rec accu2) ||
    (try aux accu1 accu2 right; true with NotEmpty -> false)


and empty_rec_arrow c =
  List.for_all empty_rec_arrow_aux c

and empty_rec_arrow_aux (left,right) =
  let single_right (s1,s2) =
    let rec aux accu1 accu2 = function
      | (t1,t2)::left ->
          let accu1' = diff_t accu1 t1 in
          if not (empty_rec accu1') then aux accu1' accu2 left;
          let accu2' = cap_t accu2 t2 in
          if not (empty_rec accu2') then aux accu1 accu2' left
      | [] -> raise NotEmpty
    in
    let accu1 = descr s1 in
    (empty_rec accu1) ||
    (try aux accu1 (diff any (descr s2)) left; true with NotEmpty -> false)
  in
  List.exists single_right right

and empty_rec_record_aux (labels,(oleft,left),rights) =
  let rec aux = function
    | [] -> raise NotEmpty
    | (oright,right)::rights ->
	let next =
	  (oleft && (not oright)) ||
	  exists (Array.length left)
	    (fun i ->
	       trivially_empty (cap left.(i) right.(i)))
	in
	if next then aux rights 
	else
	  for i = 0 to Array.length left - 1 do
	    let back = left.(i) in
	    let di = diff back right.(i) in
	    if not (empty_rec di) then (
	      left.(i) <- diff back right.(i);
	      aux rights;
	      left.(i) <- back;
	    )
	  done
  in
  exists (Array.length left) 
    (fun i -> empty_rec left.(i))
  ||
  (try aux rights; true with NotEmpty -> false)
	    

and empty_rec_record c =
  List.for_all empty_rec_record_aux (get_record c)

(*
let is_empty d =
  empty_rec d
  *)

let non_empty d = 
  not (is_empty d)

let subtype d1 d2 =
  is_empty (diff d1 d2)

module Product =
struct
  type t = (descr * descr) list

  let other ?(kind=`Normal) d = 
    match kind with
      | `Normal -> { d with times = empty.times }
      | `XML -> { d with xml = empty.xml }

  let is_product ?kind d = is_empty (other ?kind d)

  let need_second = function _::_::_ -> true | _ -> false

  let normal_aux d =
    let res = ref [] in

    let add (t1,t2) =
      let rec loop t1 t2 = function
	| [] -> res := (ref (t1,t2)) :: !res
	| ({contents = (d1,d2)} as r)::l ->
	    (*OPT*) 
(*	    if equal_descr d1 t1 then r := (d1,cup d2 t2) else*)
	      
	      let i = cap t1 d1 in
	      if is_empty i then loop t1 t2 l
	      else (
		r := (i, cup t2 d2);
		let k = diff d1 t1 in 
		if non_empty k then res := (ref (k,d2)) :: !res;
		
		let j = diff t1 d1 in 
		if non_empty j then loop j t2 l
	      )
      in
      loop t1 t2 !res
    in
    List.iter add d;
    List.map (!) !res

(*
This version explodes when dealing with
   Any - [ t1? t2? t3? ... tn? ]
==> need partitioning 
*)
  let get_aux d =
    let line accu (left,right) =
      let rec aux accu d1 d2 = function
	| (t1,t2)::right ->
	    let accu = 
	      let d1 = diff_t d1 t1 in
              if is_empty d1 then accu else aux accu d1 d2 right in
	    let accu =
              let d2 = diff_t d2 t2 in
              if is_empty d2 then accu else aux accu d1 d2 right in
	    accu
	| [] -> (d1,d2) :: accu
      in
      let (d1,d2) = cap_product left in
      if (is_empty d1) || (is_empty d2) then accu else aux accu d1 d2 right
    in
    List.fold_left line [] d

(* Partitioning:

(t,s) - ((t1,s1) | (t2,s2) | ... | (tn,sn))
=
(t & t1, s - s1) | ... | (t & tn, s - sn) | (t - (t1|...|tn), s)

*)
  let get_aux d =
    let accu = ref [] in
    let line (left,right) =
      let (d1,d2) = cap_product left in
      if (non_empty d1) && (non_empty d2) then
	let right = List.map (fun (t1,t2) -> descr t1, descr t2) right in
	let right = normal_aux right in
	let resid1 = ref d1 in
	let () = 
	  List.iter
	    (fun (t1,t2) ->
	       let t1 = cap d1 t1 in
	       if (non_empty t1) then
		 let () = resid1 := diff !resid1 t1 in
		 let t2 = diff d2 t2 in
		 if (non_empty t2) then accu := (t1,t2) :: !accu
	    ) right in
	if non_empty !resid1 then accu := (!resid1, d2) :: !accu 
    in
    List.iter line (BoolPair.get d);
    !accu
(* Maybe, can improve this function with:
     (t,s) \ (t1,s1) = (t&t',s\s') | (t\t',s),
   don't call normal_aux *)


  let get ?(kind=`Normal) d = 
    match kind with
      | `Normal -> get_aux d.times
      | `XML -> get_aux d.xml

  let pi1 = List.fold_left (fun acc (t1,_) -> cup acc t1) empty
  let pi2 = List.fold_left (fun acc (_,t2) -> cup acc t2) empty
  let pi2_restricted restr = 
    List.fold_left (fun acc (t1,t2) -> 
		      if is_empty (cap t1 restr) then acc
		      else cup acc t2) empty

  let restrict_1 rects pi1 =
    let aux acc (t1,t2) = 
      let t1 = cap t1 pi1 in if is_empty t1 then acc else (t1,t2)::acc in
    List.fold_left aux [] rects
  
  type normal = t

  module Memo = Map.Make(struct type t = descr BoolPair.t let compare = BoolPair.compare end)


  let memo = ref Memo.empty
  let normal ?(kind=`Normal) d = 
    let d = match kind with `Normal -> d.times | `XML -> d.xml in
    try Memo.find d !memo 
    with
	Not_found ->
	  let gd = get_aux d in
	  let n = normal_aux gd in
(* Could optimize this call to normal_aux because one already
   know that each line is normalized ... *)
	  memo := Memo.add d n !memo;
	  n

  let any = { empty with times = any.times }
  and any_xml = { empty with xml = any.xml }
  let is_empty d = d = []
end

module Print = 
struct
  let rec print_union ppf = function
    | [] -> Format.fprintf ppf "Empty"
    | [h] -> h ppf
    | h::t -> Format.fprintf ppf "@[%t |@ %a@]" h print_union t

  let print_tag ppf a =
    match Atoms.is_atom a with
      | Some a -> Format.fprintf ppf "%s" (Atoms.value a)
      | None -> Format.fprintf ppf "(%a)" print_union (Atoms.print a)

  let print_const ppf = function
    | Integer i -> Intervals.print_v ppf i
    | Atom a -> Atoms.print_v ppf a
    | Char c -> Chars.print_v ppf c

  let named = State.ref "Types.Printf.named" DescrMap.empty
  let register_global name d = 
    named := DescrMap.add d name !named

  let marks = DescrHash.create 63
  let wh = ref []
  let count_name = ref 0
  let name () =
    incr count_name;
    "X" ^ (string_of_int !count_name)
(* TODO: 
   check that these generated names does not conflict with declared types *)

  let trivial_rec b = b = BoolRec.empty || b = BoolRec.full
  let trivial_pair b = b = BoolPair.empty || b = BoolPair.full

  let worth_abbrev d = 
    not (trivial_pair d.times && trivial_pair d.xml && 
	 trivial_pair d.arrow && trivial_rec d.record) 

  let rec mark n = mark_descr (descr n)
  and mark_descr d =
    if not (DescrMap.mem d !named) then
      try 
	let r = DescrHash.find marks d in
	if (!r = None) && (worth_abbrev d) then 
	  let na = name () in 
	  r := Some na;
	  wh := (na,d) :: !wh
      with Not_found -> 
	DescrHash.add marks d (ref None);
    	BoolPair.iter (fun (n1,n2) -> mark n1; mark n2) d.times;
    	BoolPair.iter 
	  (fun (n1,n2) -> mark n1; mark n2
(*
	     List.iter
	       (fun (d1,d2) ->
		  mark_descr d2;
    		  bool_iter 
		    (fun (o,l) -> List.iter (fun (l,(o,n)) -> mark n) l) 
		    d1.record
		  let l = get_record d1.record in
		  List.iter (fun labs,(_,(_,p)),ns ->
			       Array.iter mark_descr p;
			       List.iter (fun (_,(_,n)) -> 
					    Array.iter mark_descr n) ns
			    ) l
	       )
	       (Product.normal (descr n2))
*)
	  ) d.xml;
	BoolPair.iter (fun (n1,n2) -> mark n1; mark n2) d.arrow;
    	BoolRec.iter 
	  (fun (o,l) -> List.iter (fun (l,n) -> mark n) (LabelMap.get l)) 
	  d.record

    
  let rec print ppf n = print_descr ppf (descr n)
  and print_descr ppf d = 
    try 
      let name = DescrMap.find d !named in
      Format.fprintf ppf "%s" name
    with Not_found ->
      try
      	match !(DescrHash.find marks d) with
      	  | Some n -> Format.fprintf ppf "%s" n
      	  | None -> real_print_descr ppf d
      with
	  Not_found -> assert false
  and real_print_descr ppf d = 
    if d = any then Format.fprintf ppf "Any" else
      (
	if d.absent then Format.fprintf ppf "?";
	print_union ppf 
	  (Intervals.print d.ints @
	   Chars.print d.chars @
	   Atoms.print d.atoms @
	   BoolPair.print "Pair" print_times d.times @
	   BoolPair.print "XML" print_xml d.xml @
	   BoolPair.print "Arrow" print_arrow d.arrow @
	   BoolRec.print "Record" print_record d.record
	  )
      )
  and print_times ppf (t1,t2) =
    Format.fprintf ppf "@[(%a,%a)@]" print t1 print t2
  and print_xml ppf (t1,t2) =
    Format.fprintf ppf "@[XML(%a,%a)@]" print t1 print t2
(*
    let l = Product.normal (descr t2) in
    let l = List.map
	      (fun (d1,d2) ppf ->
		 Format.fprintf ppf "@[<><%a%a>%a@]" 
		   print_tag (descr t1).atoms
		   print_attribs d1.record 
		   print_descr d2) l
    in
    print_union ppf l
*)
  and print_arrow ppf (t1,t2) =
    Format.fprintf ppf "@[(%a -> %a)@]" print t1 print t2
  and print_record ppf (o,r) =
    let o = if o then "" else "|" in
    Format.fprintf ppf "@[{%s" o;
    let first = ref true in
    List.iter (fun (l,t) ->
		 let sep = if !first then (first := false; "") else ";" in
		 Format.fprintf ppf "%s@ @[%s =@] %a" sep
		   (LabelPool.value l) print t
	      ) (LabelMap.get r);
    Format.fprintf ppf " %s}@]" o
(*
  and print_attribs ppf r =
    let l = get_record r in
    if l <> [ [] ] then 
    let l = List.map 
      (fun att ppf ->
	 let first = ref true in
	 Format.fprintf ppf "{" ;
	 List.iter (fun (l,(o,d)) ->
		      Format.fprintf ppf "%s%s=%s%a" 
		        (if !first then "" else " ")
		        (LabelPool.value l) (if o then "?" else "")
		        print_descr d; 
		      first := false
		   ) att;
	   Format.fprintf ppf "}"
      ) l in
    print_union ppf l
*)

	  
  let end_print ppf =
    Format.fprintf ppf "@]";
    (match List.rev !wh with
       | [] -> ()
       | (na,d)::t ->
	   Format.fprintf ppf " where@ @[%s = %a" na real_print_descr d;
	   List.iter 
	     (fun (na,d) -> 
		Format.fprintf ppf " and@ %s = %a" na real_print_descr d)
	     t;
	   Format.fprintf ppf "@]"
    );
(*    Format.fprintf ppf "@]"; *)
    count_name := 0;
    wh := [];
    DescrHash.clear marks

  let print_descr ppf d =
    mark_descr d;
    Format.fprintf ppf "@[%a" print_descr d;
    end_print ppf

   let print ppf n = print_descr ppf (descr n)

end

let () = print_descr := Print.print_descr

module Positive =
struct
  type rhs = [ `Type of descr | `Cup of v list | `Times of v * v | `Xml of v * v ]
  and v = { mutable def : rhs; mutable node : node option }


  let rec make_descr seen v =
    if List.memq v seen then empty
    else
      let seen = v :: seen in
      match v.def with
	| `Type d -> d
	| `Cup vl -> 
	    List.fold_left (fun acc v -> cup acc (make_descr seen v)) empty vl
	| `Times (v1,v2) -> times (make_node v1) (make_node v2)
	| `Xml (v1,v2) -> xml (make_node v1) (make_node v2)

  and make_node v =
    match v.node with
      | Some n -> n
      | None ->
	  let n = make () in
	  v.node <- Some n;
	  let d = make_descr [] v in
	  define n d;
	  n

  let forward () = { def = `Cup []; node = None }
  let def v d = v.def <- d
  let cons d = let v = forward () in def v d; v
  let ty d = cons (`Type d)
  let cup vl = cons (`Cup vl)
  let times d1 d2 = cons (`Times (d1,d2))
  let xml d1 d2 = cons (`Xml (d1,d2))
  let define v1 v2 = def v1 (`Cup [v2]) 

  let solve v = internalize (make_node v)
end




(* Sample value *)
module Sample =
struct


let rec find f = function
  | [] -> raise Not_found
  | x::r -> try f x with Not_found -> find f r

type t =
  | Int of Intervals.v
  | Atom of Atoms.v
  | Char of Chars.v
  | Pair of (t * t)
  | Xml of (t * t)
  | Record of (bool * (label * t) list)
  | Fun of (node * node) list
  | Other
 exception FoundSampleRecord of bool * (label * t) list

let rec sample_rec memo d =
  if (Assumptions.mem d memo) || (is_empty d) then raise Not_found 
  else 
    try Int (Intervals.sample d.ints) with Not_found ->
    try Atom (Atoms.sample d.atoms) with 
	Not_found ->
(* Here: could create a fresh atom ... *)
    try Char (Chars.sample d.chars) with Not_found ->
    try sample_rec_arrow (BoolPair.get d.arrow) with Not_found ->

    let memo = Assumptions.add d memo in
    try Pair (sample_rec_times memo (BoolPair.get d.times)) with Not_found ->
    try Xml (sample_rec_times memo (BoolPair.get d.xml)) with Not_found ->
    try sample_rec_record memo d.record with Not_found -> 
    raise Not_found


and sample_rec_times memo c = 
  find (sample_rec_times_aux memo) c

and sample_rec_times_aux memo (left,right) =
  let rec aux accu1 accu2 = function
    | (t1,t2)::right ->
(*TODO: check: is this correct ?  non_empty could return true
  but because of coinduction, the call to aux may raise Not_found, no ? *)
        let accu1' = diff_t accu1 t1 in
        if non_empty accu1' then aux accu1' accu2 right else
          let accu2' = diff_t accu2 t2 in
          if non_empty accu2' then aux accu1 accu2' right else
	    raise Not_found
    | [] -> (sample_rec memo accu1, sample_rec memo accu2)
  in
  let (accu1,accu2) = cap_product left in
  if (is_empty accu1) || (is_empty accu2) then raise Not_found;
  aux accu1 accu2 right

and sample_rec_arrow c =
  find sample_rec_arrow_aux c

and check_empty_simple_arrow_line left (s1,s2) = 
  let rec aux accu1 accu2 = function
    | (t1,t2)::left ->
        let accu1' = diff_t accu1 t1 in
        if non_empty accu1' then aux accu1 accu2 left;
        let accu2' = cap_t accu2 t2 in
        if non_empty accu2' then aux accu1 accu2 left
    | [] -> raise NotEmpty
  in
  let accu1 = descr s1 in
  (is_empty accu1) ||
  (try aux accu1 (diff any (descr s2)) left; true with NotEmpty -> false)

and check_empty_arrow_line left right = 
  List.exists (check_empty_simple_arrow_line left) right

and sample_rec_arrow_aux (left,right) =
  if (check_empty_arrow_line left right) then raise Not_found
  else Fun left


and sample_rec_record memo c =
  Record (find (sample_rec_record_aux memo) (get_record c))

and sample_rec_record_aux memo (labels,(oleft,left),rights) =
  let rec aux = function
    | [] -> 
	let l = ref labels and fields = ref [] in
	for i = 0 to Array.length left - 1 do
	  fields := (List.hd !l, sample_rec memo left.(i))::!fields;
	  l := List.tl !l
	done;
	raise (FoundSampleRecord (oleft, List.rev !fields))
    | (oright,right)::rights ->